How Good of a GM Are You?

[BroncoMan4ever]

Everyone every year has what they believe is a great draft plan. After several years of drafting let's see where our imaginary franchises would be if we were callibg the shots. How good or bad of a team would you have made if you were the shotcaller on a team. Use your best players from your draft picks and compare who is good at drafting and who needs lessons.

Undrafted picks are also usable in this game.

[BroncoMan4ever]

Just using players I have drafted or got undrafted that are still in the league my team would be average at best

Listed best to worst

QB - Nick Foles, Blaine Gabbert
RB - Le'Veon Bell, Doug Martin, Rashad Jennings, Spencer Ware
WR - Keenan Allen, Andre Roberts, Darius Heyward Bey, Dan Buckner
TE - Nick Kasa
OL - David DeCastro, Charles Brown

DL - Corey Peters,Allen Bailey, AJ Francis, Joe Kruger
LB - Kiko Alonso, Vontaze Burfict, Casey Matthews, Kevin Minter
CB - Jayron Hosley, Chris Cook
SS - Brandan Bishop

Judging myself I pick decently on RB and LB. Need help on trench players. Need work on secondary

[jebures]

QB Mike Glennon North Carolina St. 2013 (Vikings)
QB Tyrod Taylor Virginia Tech 2011 #197 (Jaguars)
QB Mike Kafka Northwestern 2010 #251 (Raiders)
QB Mike Hermann RPI 2013 UDFA (Vikings)
<?xml:namespace prefix = "o" ns = "urn:schemas-microsoft-comfficeffice" /><o:p></o:p>
RB Andre Ellington Clemson 2013 #155 (Vikings)
RB Bobby Rainey Western Kentucky 2012 UDFA (Eagles)
RB Ryan Williams Virginia Tech 2011 #64 (Jaguars)
RB Chris Polk Washington 2012 #77 (Eagles)
RB LaTavius Murray Central Florida 2013 UDFA (Vikings)
RB Alphonso Smith Kentucky 2010 UDFA (Raiders)
RB Alvester Alexander Wyoming 2012 UDFA (Eagles)
RB D.J. Harper Boise St. 2013 UDFA (Vikings)
RB Andre Anderson Tulane 2010 UDFA (Raiders)
<o:p></o:p>
FB Joe Martinek Rutgers 2012 UDFA (Eagles)
<o:p></o:p>
WR A.J. Green Georgia 2011 #9 (Jaguars)
WR Terrence Williams Baylor 2013 #30 (Vikings)
WR Kenny Stills Oklahoma 2013 #133 (Vikings)
WR Marlon Brown Georgia 2013 UDFA (Vikings)
WR Ryan Broyles Oklahoma 2012 #178 (Eagles)
WR Brice Butler San Diego St. 2013 UDFA (Vikings)
WR Stephen Burton West Texas A&M 2011 #233 (Jaguars)
WR Quincy McDuffie Central Florida 2013 UDFA (Vikings)
WR Scott Long Louisville 2010 UDFA (Raiders)
WR JeRon Harris South Dakota St. 2009 #231 (Vikings)
<o:p></o:p>
TE Jared Cook South Carolina 2009 #54 (Vikings)
TE Luke Willson Rice 2013 UDFA (Vikings)
TE James Hannah Oklahoma 2012 #154 (Eagles)
TE Taylor Thompson SMU 2012 #217 (Eagles)
TE Jameson Konz Kent St. 2010 #225 (Raiders)
<o:p></o:p>
T Trent Williams Oklahoma 2010 #8 (Raiders)
T Donald Stephenson Oklahoma 2012 #189 (Eagles)
T James Brewer Indiana 2011 #122 (Jaguars)
T Selvish Capers West Virginia 2010 #106 (Raiders)
T Troy Kropog Tulane 2009 #86 (Vikings)
T Jake Bscherer Minnesota Duluth UDFA (Vikings)
<o:p></o:p>
G Kevin Zeitler Wisconsin 2011 #51 (Eagles)
G Dorian Brooks Maryland 2010 UDFA (Raiders)
<o:p></o:p>
C Ryan Jensen Colorado St. Pueblo 2013 #189 (Vikings)
C Ryan Bartholomew Syracuse 2011 UDFA (Jaguars)
<o:p></o:p>
DT Michael Brockers LSU 2012 #15 (Eagles)
DT Linval Joseph East Carolina 2010 #85 (Raiders)
DT Earl Mitchell Arizona 2010 #215 (Raiders)
DT Vance Walker Georgia Tech 2009 #158 (Vikings)
DT Montari Hughes Tennessee Martin 2013 #127 (Vikings)
DT Markus Kuhn North Carolina St. 2012 UDFA (Eagles)
<o:p></o:p>
DE Jason Pierre-Paul South Florida 2010 #18 (Raiders)
DE Whitney Mercilus Illinois 2012 #38 (Eagles)
DE Malliciah Goodman Clemson 2013 #102 (Vikings)
DE Kyle Wilbur Wake Forest 2012 #197 (Eagles)
DE Rufus Johnson Tarleton St. 2013 UDFA (Vikings)
DE Brandon Long Michigan St. 2009 #221 (Vikings)
<o:p></o:p>
MLB Jonathan Bostic Florida 2013 #120 (Vikings)
MLB Mario Harvey Marshall 2011 #182 (Jaguars)
MLB Nathan Triplett Minnesota 2010 UDFA (Raiders)
<o:p></o:p>
OLB Khaseem Grenee Rutgers 2013 (Vikings)
OLB Chris Carter Fresno St. 2011 #96 (Jaguars)
OLB Lerentee McCray Florida 2013 #213 (Vikings)
<o:p></o:p>
CB Vontae Davis Illinois 2009 #23 (Vikings)
CB Sam Shields Miami 2010 UDFA (Raiders)
CB Leonard Johnson Iowa St. 2012 #117 (Eagles)
CB Chimdi Chekwa Ohio St. 2011 #115 (Jaguars)
CB Trevin Wade Arizona 2012 #209 (Eagles)
CB Walter McFadden Auburn 2010 #158 (Raiders)
<o:p></o:p>
S Chris Culliver South Carolina 2011 #147 (Jaguars)
S Chris Proskinski Wyoming 2011 UDFA (Jaguars)
S Don Jones Arkansas St. 2013 UDFA (Arkansas St.)
S D.J. Campbell California 2012 UDFA (Eagles)
S Bradley McDougald Kansas 2013 #229 (Vikings)
<o:p></o:p>
P Bryan Anger California 2012 UDFA (Eagles)
P Matt Bosher Miami 2011 UDFA (Jaguars)
P Derek Epperson Baylor 2011 UDFA (Jaguars)
P Taylor Accardi Colorado Mines 2013 UDFA (Vikings)

[BroncoMan4ever]

QB Mike Glennon North Carolina St. 2013 (Vikings)
QB Tyrod Taylor Virginia Tech 2011 #197 (Jaguars)
QB Mike Kafka Northwestern 2010 #251 (Raiders)
QB Mike Hermann RPI 2013 UDFA (Vikings)
<?xml:namespace prefix = "o" ns = "urn:schemas-microsoft-comfficeffice" /><o:p></o:p>
RB Andre Ellington Clemson 2013 #155 (Vikings)
RB Bobby Rainey Western Kentucky 2012 UDFA (Eagles)
RB Ryan Williams Virginia Tech 2011 #64 (Jaguars)
RB Chris Polk Washington 2012 #77 (Eagles)
RB LaTavius Murray Central Florida 2013 UDFA (Vikings)
RB Alphonso Smith Kentucky 2010 UDFA (Raiders)
RB Alvester Alexander Wyoming 2012 UDFA (Eagles)
RB D.J. Harper Boise St. 2013 UDFA (Vikings)
RB Andre Anderson Tulane 2010 UDFA (Raiders)
<o:p></o:p>
FB Joe Martinek Rutgers 2012 UDFA (Eagles)
<o:p></o:p>
WR A.J. Green Georgia 2011 #9 (Jaguars)
WR Terrence Williams Baylor 2013 #30 (Vikings)
WR Kenny Stills Oklahoma 2013 #133 (Vikings)
WR Marlon Brown Georgia 2013 UDFA (Vikings)
WR Ryan Broyles Oklahoma 2012 #178 (Eagles)
WR Brice Butler San Diego St. 2013 UDFA (Vikings)
WR Stephen Burton West Texas A&M 2011 #233 (Jaguars)
WR Quincy McDuffie Central Florida 2013 UDFA (Vikings)
WR Scott Long Louisville 2010 UDFA (Raiders)
WR JeRon Harris South Dakota St. 2009 #231 (Vikings)
<o:p></o:p>
TE Jared Cook South Carolina 2009 #54 (Vikings)
TE Luke Willson Rice 2013 UDFA (Vikings)
TE James Hannah Oklahoma 2012 #154 (Eagles)
TE Taylor Thompson SMU 2012 #217 (Eagles)
TE Jameson Konz Kent St. 2010 #225 (Raiders)
<o:p></o:p>
T Trent Williams Oklahoma 2010 #8 (Raiders)
T Donald Stephenson Oklahoma 2012 #189 (Eagles)
T James Brewer Indiana 2011 #122 (Jaguars)
T Selvish Capers West Virginia 2010 #106 (Raiders)
T Troy Kropog Tulane 2009 #86 (Vikings)
T Jake Bscherer Minnesota Duluth UDFA (Vikings)
<o:p></o:p>
G Kevin Zeitler Wisconsin 2011 #51 (Eagles)
G Dorian Brooks Maryland 2010 UDFA (Raiders)
<o:p></o:p>
C Ryan Jensen Colorado St. Pueblo 2013 #189 (Vikings)
C Ryan Bartholomew Syracuse 2011 UDFA (Jaguars)
<o:p></o:p>
DT Michael Brockers LSU 2012 #15 (Eagles)
DT Linval Joseph East Carolina 2010 #85 (Raiders)
DT Earl Mitchell Arizona 2010 #215 (Raiders)
DT Vance Walker Georgia Tech 2009 #158 (Vikings)
DT Montari Hughes Tennessee Martin 2013 #127 (Vikings)
DT Markus Kuhn North Carolina St. 2012 UDFA (Eagles)
<o:p></o:p>
DE Jason Pierre-Paul South Florida 2010 #18 (Raiders)
DE Whitney Mercilus Illinois 2012 #38 (Eagles)
DE Malliciah Goodman Clemson 2013 #102 (Vikings)
DE Kyle Wilbur Wake Forest 2012 #197 (Eagles)
DE Rufus Johnson Tarleton St. 2013 UDFA (Vikings)
DE Brandon Long Michigan St. 2009 #221 (Vikings)
<o:p></o:p>
MLB Jonathan Bostic Florida 2013 #120 (Vikings)
MLB Mario Harvey Marshall 2011 #182 (Jaguars)
MLB Nathan Triplett Minnesota 2010 UDFA (Raiders)
<o:p></o:p>
OLB Khaseem Grenee Rutgers 2013 (Vikings)
OLB Chris Carter Fresno St. 2011 #96 (Jaguars)
OLB Lerentee McCray Florida 2013 #213 (Vikings)
<o:p></o:p>
CB Vontae Davis Illinois 2009 #23 (Vikings)
CB Sam Shields Miami 2010 UDFA (Raiders)
CB Leonard Johnson Iowa St. 2012 #117 (Eagles)
CB Chimdi Chekwa Ohio St. 2011 #115 (Jaguars)
CB Trevin Wade Arizona 2012 #209 (Eagles)
CB Walter McFadden Auburn 2010 #158 (Raiders)
<o:p></o:p>
S Chris Culliver South Carolina 2011 #147 (Jaguars)
S Chris Proskinski Wyoming 2011 UDFA (Jaguars)
S Don Jones Arkansas St. 2013 UDFA (Arkansas St.)
S D.J. Campbell California 2012 UDFA (Eagles)
S Bradley McDougald Kansas 2013 #229 (Vikings)
<o:p></o:p>
P Bryan Anger California 2012 UDFA (Eagles)
P Matt Bosher Miami 2011 UDFA (Jaguars)
P Derek Epperson Baylor 2011 UDFA (Jaguars)
P Taylor Accardi Colorado Mines 2013 UDFA (Vikings)

God damn that is a ****load of picks.

[Requiem]

QB: Joe Flacco
RB: Marshawn Lynch, Lamar Miller and Giovanni Bernard
WR: DeAndre Hopkins, Leonard Hankerson and Jermaine Kearse
OL: Cordy Glenn

DE: Quinton Coples
DT: Muhammed Wilkerson
LB: Alec Ogletree, Wesley Woodyard
CB: Aqib Talib, Casey Heyward
S: Jonathan Cyprien

Just off the head notables. I have always been teams drafting late. Never had a shot at elite guys. On my mobile now and when I look at my history I never drafted a TE or too many offensive lineman. I had a few years where MUG and someone else took over for me, but overall not too shabby. Busted big time on Brandon Harris a few years back and have made some dumb premptive trades to just pick early and be done. Past two seasons were pretty good. Looking forward to doing something different and having another new team.

[Rohirrim]

QB: Joe Flacco
RB: Marshawn Lynch, Lamar Miller and Giovanni Bernard
WR: DeAndre Hopkins, Leonard Hankerson and Jermaine Kearse
OL: Cordy Glenn

DE: Quinton Coples
DT: Muhammed Wilkerson
LB: Alec Ogletree, Wesley Woodyard
CB: Aqib Talib, Casey Heyward
S: Jonathan Cyprien

Just off the head notables. I have always been teams drafting late. Never had a shot at elite guys. On my mobile now and when I look at my history I never drafted a TE or too many offensive lineman. I had a few years where MUG and someone else took over for me, but overall not too shabby. Busted big time on Brandon Harris a few years back and have made some dumb premptive trades to just pick early and be done. Past two seasons were pretty good. Looking forward to doing something different and having another new team.

On the other hand, when you're drafting really high, your pick is almost made for you.

[ColoradoBuff]

QB: Matt Leinart, Graham Harrell
RB: Arian Foster (6th round pick), Kevin Smith, Daniel Thomas, Marcus Lattimore (futures pick)
WR: Kendall Wright, Jason Avant, Quinton Patton, Aldrick Robinson
TE: Scott Chandler
T: Andre Smith, Phil Loadhalt
G: Chilo Rachal, Will Rackley, Amini Silatolu
C: JD Walton

DE: Greg Hardy, Olivier Vernon
DT: Sammie Lee Hill, Henry Melton, Stephen Paea
LB: Bruce Carter, Ernie Sims
CB: Dee Millner
S: Thomas Decoud, Daniel Manning, Malcom Jenkins, William Moore, JJ Wilcox

[BroncosfanGuy]

WR A.J. Green Georgia 2011 #9 (Jaguars)
WR Terrence Williams Baylor 2013 #30 (Vikings)
WR Kenny Stills Oklahoma 2013 #133 (Vikings)
WR Marlon Brown Georgia 2013 UDFA (Vikings)
WR Ryan Broyles Oklahoma 2012 #178 (Eagles)

Dude. send your 2014 WR list to the Broncos FO. that's impressive stuff

[jebures]

Dude. send your 2014 WR list to the Broncos FO. that's impressive stuff

That is my favorite position, probably what I do the most research into, and I guess it showed during my drafts. Found good players later in the draft. Actually traded up to get A.J. Green in the other Mock b.c I couldn't believe he fell that far.

[Mediator12]

These are my most successful draftees. Some were damn easy like Luck and Calvin Johnson. However, I also had a lot of success in UDFA with players the Colts either selected or made their way to their team highlighted in Blue. Most were selected by Indianapolis colts drafting at end of the round, and without a full selection of picks thanks to Bill "I can only draft cover 2" Polian's ineptitude.

QB: Andrew Luck, Chandler Harnish (both for Colts)
WR: Calvin Johnson, Pierre Garcon and TY Hilton (Both For Colts), David Gettis, Darius Reynaud
TE: James Casey
RB: Joseph Addai (for Colts), Stepfan Taylor
OT: Roger Saffold, Gabe Carimi
OG: Rob Sims, Evan Mathis, Clint Boling
OC: Never drafted.....

DT: Tyson Alualu, Bennie Logan, Ray McDonald, Eric Foster(UDFA), Dorell Scott,
DE: Chandler Jones, Malik Jackson
OLB: Clay Matthews, Deandre Levy (UDFA)
ILB: Nigel Bradham, Stewart Bradley
CB: Patrick Robinson, Bradley Fletcher, Don Carey (UDFA), Marcus Gilcrest, Steve Williams
S: Harrison Smith, Robert Blanton, Charles Godfrey, Tyrell Johnson, Sherrod Martin

2008 FA Notables: Pierre Garcon, Reggie Corner, Eric Foster
2009 FA Notables: Don Carey, Ashlee Palmer, and Deandre Levy still playing
2010 FA Notables: David Reed (WR/KR) still playing
2012 FA Notables: Jeremy Lane (CB SEA), Chandler Harnish (drafted by Colts), DeAngelo Tyson, Travian Robertson all still active players
2013 FA Notables: Edmund Kugbila and Jake Knott

All in all, I would compete with this team I believe in the NFL. Not sure I would win 50% of my games, but I would take any team drafted from the OM draft

[BMORE]

Dude. send your 2014 WR list to the Broncos FO. that's impressive stuff

Considering how many flops there are at the WR position, that is impressive stuff!

[Rohirrim]

I haven't drafted enough at every position to make a team. I've only taken two QBs, and that was in the final rounds.

QB - Matt Flynn

Did a little better with receivers

WR - Michael Crabtree, Robert Woods, Reuben Randle, Robert Meachem, Tiquan Underwood

TE - Coby Fleener, Travis Kelce

Never drafted a RB, just FB

FB - Brian Leonard

DBs - Patrick Chung, Charles Godfrey, Mo Claiborne, Jamar Taylor

LB - Travis Lewis, AJ Klein

DT - Nick Fairley, Dan Williams

DE - Adrian Clayborn, Austen Lane, Jerel Worthy

OL - DJ Fluker, Tom Compton, Dallas Thomas, Eric Cook, Mike Otto, Lee Ziemba

[Arkie]

very thin at middle linebacker

QB: Cam Newton, Josh Freeman
RB: Jahvid Best, Ronnie Hillman
WR: Mike Wallace, Steve Johnson, Danario Alexander, Kembrell Thompkins, Armon Binns, Darius Johnson
TE: Fred Davis
OT: Andre Smith, Will Beatty, Lamar Holmes, Marcus Cannon
OG: Davin Joseph, Jason Spitz, Brandon Fusco, Chris Scott

DT: B.J. Raji, Jurrell Casey, Dontari Poe, Ricky Jean-Francois, Marcus Harrison
DE: Derrick Harvey, Andre Branch, Dion Jordan
OLB: Geno Hayes, Keith Ellison
ILB: Chris White
CB: Antonio Cromartie
S: Kam Chancellor, Tyvon Branch, Matt Elam, Quinton Carter

[jebures]

very thin at middle linebacker

QB: Cam Newton, Josh Freeman
RB: Jahvid Best, Ronnie Hillman
WR: Mike Wallace, Steve Johnson, Danario Alexander, Kembrell Thompkins, Armon Binns, Darius Johnson
TE: Fred Davis
OT: Andre Smith, Will Beatty, Lamar Holmes, Marcus Cannon
OG: Davin Joseph, Jason Spitz, Brandon Fusco, Chris Scott

DT: B.J. Raji, Jurrell Casey, Dontari Poe, Ricky Jean-Francois, Marcus Harrison
DE: Derrick Harvey, Andre Branch, Dion Jordan
OLB: Geno Hayes, Keith Ellison
ILB: Chris White
CB: Antonio Cromartie
S: Kam Chancellor, Tyvon Branch, Matt Elam, Quinton Carter

awesome DT and Safeties

[24champ]

QB: Vince Young, Jake Locker, Levi Brown
HB: Ryan Torain, CJ Spiller, LaMichael James
FB: Frank Summers, Lonnie Pryor
OL: William Robinson, Pedro Sosa, Jason Smith, Duke Robinson, John Asmoah, Kyle Long, Khaled Jones,
TE: Anthony Mix, Brian Lithicum
WR: Drouzon Quillen, Harry Douglas, Earl Bennett, Derrick Williams, Ricardo Lockette, Stephen Hill, Aaron Dobson, Alec Lemon
DT: John McCargo, Andre Fluellen, Sione Fua, Akeem Spence
DE: Manny Lawson, Louis Holmes, Will Davis, JJ Watt, Marcus Forston, Kourtnei Brown, Datone Jones
LB: Nick Reid, Dan Connor, Jason Phillips, Perry Riley, D'uandre Reed, Trevardo Williams
CB: Orlando Scandrick, Kareem Jackson, Alterraun Verner, Jalil Brown, Asa Jackson
S: Kenny Phillips, Louis Delmas, Kurt Coleman, Colin Jones, Winston Guy, Tony Jefferson


Strengths: Running game and secondary.
Weakness: Passing game. QBs are hot garbage and so is the receiving corp with one or two exceptions.