Most valuable players on the roster.. Who's your top 5?

[ATL-Eric]

I.e. which players could we least afford to lose?

1. 18
2. Talib
3. Von
4. Ball
5. Tie. Ware & DT. Bubba could probably step in.

[Rabb]

1. Manning
2. Clady
3. Ward
4. Knighton
5. Edit: I meant Vasquez...Jesus

[theAPAOps5]

1. Manning
2. CLADY
3. Manning
4. Manning
5. Manning

[Arkie]

Peyton
Clady
Von
Talib
DT

[goldengopher1976]

1. Manning
2. CLADY
3. Manning
4. Manning
5. Manning

/signed

[The1percentKid]

Obviously Manning.

The top 2 CBs Talib and Harris go out and it's problems.

[Dr. Broncenstein]

Manning
Miller
Vasqeuz
D Thomas
Trevathan

[TonyR]

Other than Manning being number one, so far it looks like opinions have changed since May.

http://www.orangemane.com/BB/showthread.php?t=115501

[Sly_Eli]

1. Manning - no explanation necessary
2. Von - defense was meh without him at his best all year
3. Clady - If you keep manning upright, you have a chance to win. He was missed in SB
4. Harris - Leader of the DBs, mr. consistency. DBs fell apart without him
5. Knighton - Held the defense together through the playoff run. Controls plays.

honorable mention to TJ Ward, Danny Trevathan, Louis Vasquez, and DT.

[ShiftyEyedWaterboy]

Peyton
Clady
Von
Talib
DT

I would swap Von and Clady. Besides that, I agree.

[Kaylore]

Not sure Clady is that important. We lost him for the season last year and it hurt us so much we set a record for points and passing touchdowns. He's better than Clark, but he probably isn't top five so long as Clark is on the team.

[LikeABoss5820]

Outside of the obvious, Manning....

No order.

Clady
Vazquez
Miller
Knighton
Talib

[strafen]

I.e. which players could we least afford to lose?

1. 18
2. Talib
3. Von
4. Ball
5. Tie. Ware & DT. Bubba could probably step in.

Ball? Montee Ball?!!!
I can name 10 players more valuable than Montee Ball before I can even consider him a top valuable player
And you don't even have Demariyus Thomas in there?
No Clady?
Bubba?

[Tombstone RJ]

1 Defensive Line
2 LBers
3 Secondary
4 Running Game
5 Oline

[ATL-Eric]

Ball? Montee Ball?!!!
I can name 10 players more valuable than Montee Ball before I can even consider him a top valuable player
And you don't even have Demariyus Thomas in there?
No Clady?
Bubba?

You have to consider replacement player value and losing Ball would force Ronnie Handtackle into a starters role and doom our offense. And I was saying I think Bubba could step in for DT and do a good job. And we won 15 games without Clady.