|10-27-2006, 07:46 AM||#1|
Ring of Famer
Join Date: Mar 2004
Elway mention Mike and Mike today ....
today Greenberg said something that iv always though but never heard or said anything about and i never agree with greenburg .... Greenie was doing a list of QBs from the past generation just gone by to today and the 5 greats from then to 5 guys today who "sorta" mirror them ....
1... of corse .... Marino to Payton .... stat compilers with no rings
2... Joe Montana to Brady ...
3... Troy Akiman to Palmer
4 Steve Young to Vick
AND 5 .... Elway to Mcnabb .... "Greenberg "saying that mcnabb has that abill to lift teams that was sub par to playoff superbowl status and that mcnabb till this point has been so close like john till he won the 2 at the end .... and the way they moved and played was very semilar cuz people to young to rember Dont rember when john could run and move like no other running qb inthe game but only when needed ...
I always thought when john retired if we could of had any qb in the league AT that time .... Mac 5 would have just ruled in the bootleg game and just reminds me of John in so many ways ....
HES NOT JOHN .... but the size . the body shape "square" .... great arm "NOT JOHNS" ..the way they both get snapped around fast on the boot and get head downfield is dead on ...... and the dudes just got heart ...
but was pretty good list ... i didnt think they would say elway to mcnabb and they waited till last to do elway .. thought never crossed my mind had about forgot it .... and as they are doing list girlfriend walks in and says it has to be Mcnabb .... Doh ... hate it when the Female outsports me ...
|10-27-2006, 08:06 AM||#3|
Ring of Famer
Join Date: May 2001
I agree, I said it after the superbowl when he "choked"
He even has the stigma of being a choke artist like Elway was at this point in his career
I'd love to have McNabb in our offense
|10-27-2006, 08:47 AM||#7|
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Cleveland, Ohio
Young to Vick is a slap in the face to a Hall of Famer...
Just because Young could run and Vick can run doesn't mean they are the same type of QB...
Check out Young's QB ratings and completion percentage...Ummm, Vick not so much.
Young was a quarterback, that could run.
Vick is a running back that has a hell of an arm.
|10-27-2006, 10:03 AM||#9|
The Kranz Dictum
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Tranquility Base
i thought McNabb looked like Elway vs Duh Bears when they played in the divisional playoff game in 2001(?), the year Duh Bears went 13-3 on lucky pick-6's at end of games.