Originally Posted by Taco John
So I'm in a keeper league with my buds. One of the guys approaches me with the following trade:
He will trade:
I hate to part with either of them, as I have such high hopes for Palmer. He was the guy I was going to build my team around. Should I pull the trigger?
In a heartbeat. You have no idea where Edgerrin James will even be playing next year. You have no idea if or at what level Carson Palmer will be playing.
On the other hand, Jackson is younger (and maybe good, although the jury is still certainly out), and Manning never misses games to injury.
You must make this trade!