just saw it last night.
the dialogue wasnt half as bad as people made it out to be, and the action was great.
if you compare to the original films, i suppose you could still be a a little disappointed, but as a stand alone film it was pretty awesome.
its FAR superior to the first two prequels, and just a notch below the originals.
i dont know now nor will i ever understand why so many people like "empire" so much, but i'd say thats the one film of the original trilogy that this one stacks up against.
in order, i'd say
1) return of the jedi
2) star wars (youll never get me to call it "episode IV")
3) tie between empire and sith
5) attack of the clones
6) phantom menace (a distant 6)