Wow, interesting take. I downloaded the CD last week, and was definately not impressed with it. I thought the last D12 album (D12 World) was terrible, and I did not think highly of Encore, leaving me wondering just what has happened to our good friend Marshall.
I think Eminem has a lot of skill, but a lot of the choruses were annoying on this album, IMO. I like... maybe half the CD at best, the rest I could do without.