Originally Posted by TonyR
Okay, so then you'd agree that he's starting caliber, right? If he's "average" then he could start for approximately half the teams in the league, right? And the fact that he did this in his rookie year would suggest he has some upside, right?
That doesn't make a player "pretty good". I'm on my phone and don't want to look up stats, but I'm willing to bet he couldn't be the starting TE on half the NFL teams.
Saints, NE, Alt, SD, Dallas, Denver, KC, Jags and Houston off the top of my head have TEs he would be behind on the depth chart. Also his rookie year was 2010. He didn't start for the Giants till 2011. He has above average number two TE upside.