Originally Posted by TheReverend
All things don't exist in a vacuum. We're talking about a game where Denver lost by 3 with no generated pass rush and surrendered 3 TDs of 59, 70 and 32 yards through the air.
You're right. All things don't exist in a vacuum, and that's why I don't assume any of the circumstances that took place in that game would've taken place in quite the same way if you trade out Miller for Peterson. I just know that we are a worse team with that trade off, and I'm not inclined to believe a worse team wins that game. And besides, if we have Peterson we probably don't have Holliday, and I'm sure not going to assume that Peterson gets two return TDs just because Holliday did.