Originally Posted by Requiem
DRC > Porter
Freeney is not Dumervil's "replacement" and at this point in their careers, I'd take Mendenhall over McGahee in a heartbeat. Think Willis fumbled more last year and lost more than Mendenhall has in his career lol.
Is DRC better than Porter? Not saying he isn't but I've always thought he's underachieved and had pretty much the same type of career as Porter. Obviously, he is better if he just stays on the field, but I don't think it's a dramatic upgrade. I'd like to see some comparisions between the two.