Originally Posted by Bmore Manning
You and I had this debate before.. Why can a rookie pass rusher not have an impact? Did Von and Aldon Smith have an impact as rookies? What about Irvin last year? Even Wolfe had 6 sacks, isn't than an impact?
Because everyone loves to make these vacuum arguments. You see, there can be no other factor at all in these things. Once you accept that, this will all make sense.
By many people's logic, if we trade player A for player B, regardless of their position...there is no other factor to think about.
Just like if we lose player A, we better draft player B and he better be just as good as player A or it's a failure.