Originally Posted by OrangeSe7en
I wasn't addressing Manning's injury. I was pointing out the flaw in your obesrvation that Peterson never came back from anything. That's completely untrue.
He missed four games, comeback player should miss more than four games regardless of injury, and otherwise he didn't really come "back". If Peterson had suffered the same injury in week 17 last year would you still want him winning comeback player of the year without actually missing time or dropping off performance-wise? That's kinda the requirement of the award.