Originally Posted by Butterscotch Stallion
I don't remember quinn or smith having a winning record or winning a playoff game in there first 16 starts..
Hmmmm, maybe my internet is broken?
Maybe you remember Vince Young, then? As a rookie, he took over an 0-3 team and led them to an 8-5 finish. Even now he's still 31-19 in his career as a starter. Yet, no one wants him to start for them. I wonder why? Could it be that the reasons for wins and losses are often more complex than who lined up under center? Hell, Kyle Orton was 27-12 after his first 39 starts (~2.5 seasons worth).