Originally Posted by SportinOne
And by the way, this is football not baseball. Throw out the stats and go with your eyes. If it weren't for McGahee's fumble issues there is not a person here who could say with a straight face that Moreno is a better running back. He shows glimpses, at times. But McGahee, although lacking top end speed to break away, is explosive. When the line was blocking he was routinely cutting up the field for 8 to 12 yards a play.
It would be nice to have both of them. It would be really nice if Hillman started to progress. It's looking like it's going to take him some time.
You can argue that McGahee was playing as well as Moreno is right now before he was injured, but only if you ignore all the stupid fumbles. I don't ignore stupid fumbles do you?