Originally Posted by MagicHef
2 obvious wins (Clady and Thomas)
2 obvious losses (Moss and Moreno)
I'm also tempted to include Cutler in obvious win based on positional value.
Compare that with Oakland (no obvious wins and 5 obvious losses).
Myself I'd rather have taken Nigota over cutlet, whose QBR hovers mid 80's and is currently 81. If his defense and ST over the past few years were not great, I'd guess his numbers would even be lower as he would be forcing the ball more.
NIgota has been consistently good to great.