Originally Posted by Hamrob
O.K. smart guy....your the GM:
You get the choice of Schaub, or:
Who do you take
Am I playing to win now or am I looking to build a team from the ground up?
If I have a Broncos getting Peyton in an all in win now move I am taking Schaub. He has shown that he can get the job done and has more NFL experience.
If I am looking to build a franchise from the ground up I take RGIII. I take him for his pure athletic ability that makes him one of the most dangerous players, leadership ability and charisma.
Look, I'm not saying Luck, RGIII and Freeman are bad or won't amount to anything. I am saying that 10 games is not enough to be proclaimed a top 10 QB. And in the case of Freeman he has been too hot and cold for my liking