Quote:
Originally Posted by Beantown Bronco
YPC and total yards are two VERY different criteria.
You're right. It's not like this guy has 37 TDs in the last 4 years worth of games or anything, splitting carries no less. Oh, wait a sec.
Now who sounds ignorant? Maroney? Really?
|
I wasn't talking criteria, I was talking about the over weighted yards in any category. YPC can eventually get a first down if he's having a game like McGahee last week, which he usually isn't. Is that what we're going to be paying for? And considering he's averaging 3.4 this year does that bring the price down? 37 TD's? Oh how clever. Let's count that one good year 5 years ago. Or are we counting returns also? Is that what we'll be paying for? Who will sound ignorant? Depending on what we would pay for him, the ones on here saying it would be great, when it turns into I-N-C-O-N-S-I-S-T-E-N-T.
Quote:
|
The panthers gave him a 44M contract 15 months ago. The guys that get paid to evaluate players saw something. I think he splits carries bc he's hurt alot and Stewart himself is a great Back. Go watch the tape. Mcgahee may have better vision, but you cant compare his speed and burst with DWills. Sorry
|
How many overblown contracts have we seen that get little to nothing for it? C'mon. I'm not saying that when DWill has a moment it's not great, I'm saying they are far and few between. For me, it's all about what we give up. I'm still bitter over the Maroney thing.