Originally Posted by Dedhed
But we do know he won't be 100% of his old self. You can spin and assume all you want. That fact will not change.
I don't need to know any specifics at all to know he's not ever going to be 100%. You don't seem to grasp that.
I never said he would be 100%, and I'm not the one making definitive statements about Manning one way or the other. You're the one definitively ruling him out, which requires him to be too far from 100% to be effective. Since you can't prove that's the case then your argument fails. Which is my whole point. I'm not sure why you're having such a hard time with this. I'm saying let the medical professionals and football professionals make the call. You're saying you've made the call.