Originally Posted by Ratboy
I KNOW Manning is better, which is why I want him.
This is not Colt McCoy we're talking about, it is Peyton Manning.
It's 36 year old Peyton Manning. Who still isn't fully healed and may never be. Who's won 1 title in 14 years.
You want to trade our promising 24 year old prospect for a guy who's likely got a year or two left, and won a single title in 14 years. With a team that was built just for him over many years.