Originally Posted by Ratboy
How can you anyone deny that a healthy Peyton Manning does not improve the entire offense?
I cannot say the same about Tebow.
I've said that repeatedly. But he's not leading this team to a title. And he's only got a couple of years, if even that.
Meanwhile we just won our first playoff game with a QB in his first season's worth of games.
You're never going to develop a QB if every time you bring a new kid in you say "But we could improve on this rook who's never played by renting this old guy over here"
As I've said before, Aaron Rodgers was a step down from Brett Favre his first year. But for long term success, eventually every team has to go through that difficult stretch.