When I first saw this thread I was like, what? Then I saw the date on it.
Why is it every two years there's some new "greatest of all time?" Kind of contradicts the theory.
And it's funny how the last guy you see is always the 'greatest.'
Manning is 9-9 in the playoffs. Easy to stand out with less competition on the field. They could vote for him as MVP ten times, and it wouldn't increase or decrease his ability or talent level in the least.