So we did Macy's and Target. I took the advice (well the normal advice) of what a lot people said here and I did what AK did and we started scanning random groceries at Super Target to see if anyone would get them. Some of them I really want to get, like the 99 cent gummy worms.
I hate Target - especially their return policy which sucks - but Amy loves it. This became a point of contention with us with us agreeing to split it up. Interestingly Macy's was cheaper than target especially on some of the big ticket items. I tagged everything I could there so that when we went to tag stuff at Target it wouldn't matter. We tagged a flat screen at Target only because they don't sell them at Macy's. Then found them for $200 cheaper at Walmart a few days ago. I pointed this out and she was kind of miffed. Stupid Target.
We did check Bed Bath and Beyond and while we found some things we liked we didn't find enough to warrant registering there after the other two places. Macy's has the discount on things we don't get, so we'll at least get that.
We are probably going to go back and update it quite a bit. I put a Wii on there and then bought one two days ago (4 games plus one nunchuck for $225. Thank you young student who looks like the kid from the creepy diesel secret dot com commercial!!!) I still haven't tagged a cutting board because I can't find one I like. I liked the one at Walmart (of course) maybe someone will get us a really classy one from Williams Sonoma.