Corey Redding, Troy Polamalu, and Logan Mankins are just a few I can think of off the top of my head. IIRC, Redding was the top defensive player in the country that year. Not a fun time for any team that happens to.
So with Gabbart leaving, does anyone's opinion of him change? I don't know how anyone deserves a 5 star rating when he gets benched during his senior year, regardless of their ceiling.