PDA

View Full Version : Why we won't be drafting McClain or Weatherspoon.


The Joker
04-20-2010, 02:21 AM
No, I'm fully prepared for looking like a fool on Thursday night, but I have to say that I just can't see any way we end up picking one of these guys when the big moment comes.

Few reasons.

Firstly, I don't see how it makes any fiscal sense whatsoever.

We're already paying DJ Williams roughly six to eight million a year. We also have Robert Ayers, last year's 1st round pick with a very nice little contract for himself. Already, that's a nice amount of money tied up in the linebacker position.

Then there's Dumervil. I just don't see any way we let the guy walk away. It flies in the face of pretty much everything McDaniels has preached since he got here. He'll get a deal, and a pretty hefty one at that.

Bearing all of this in mind, we'd be pretty much insane to go drafting another linebacker and paying him the kind of contract that we'd have to dish out to a #11 pick (or even a slightly later one, if we trade down). I know there's no salary cap this year, but when they get a new CBA figured out I'd be pretty confident that some sort of new salary cap will be part of it. If and when that happens, do we really want so much money tied up at the one position?

Then there's the fact that we'd be drafting them to essentially play the role that Andra Davis featured in for us last year.

DJ Williams seems to have the WILB position locked down, with Woodyard as his back-up.

At present we have Haggan as our starting SILB, with Larsen backing him up.

Clearly, the SILB position is the position most in need of an upgrade.

However, at the end of the day it's a spot on the field that simply isn't all that important, or at least it doesn't take an elite level of talent to play the spot well. What we need is a guy who can take on blocks well, play with discipline and be a strong physical presence up the middle and lay some wood once in a while.

Now, I happen to like McClain and Weatherspoon. I think they both have a shot at being real players for whatever team it is that picks them up on Thursday. But I just don't see how that team ends up being the Broncos.

Only way is if we're planning on trading DJ. While I don't think DJ is a special player by any means, he's far from the player I'd be most looking to move on at this point. Also, for the sake of the Mane I don't think it'd be a good thing. Socal would pretty much end worlds if it happened.

I'm firmly in the "Dan Williams at #11 or trade down and get an O-Line player and some extra picks" camp, if we go LB I'll be very confused as to what on earth the plan is.

ZONA
04-20-2010, 03:23 AM
Yup.

Exactly why I think Micah Johnson is on our radar somehwere in the 4th or 5th round. Wouldn't that be sweet. Get rid of Schef and get the 3rd pick of the 5th round and hopefully Micah is there.

http://kentuckysportsradio.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/micah1.jpg

watermock
04-20-2010, 03:30 AM
I doubt Beavis will **** up this draft so bad.

robbieopperude
04-20-2010, 03:51 AM
Anybody want Haden at 11. I guess his Pro Day was very very good and he would be a nice DB to have against the pass happy offenses of NE, Indi, SD if we ever make it to a playoff game.

DBroncos4life
04-20-2010, 05:22 AM
It's OK to run the 3-4 with two good ILB's. The Jets did it last year. They had a pretty good D. The Steelers have had success at it. The Ravens had Bart Scott and Ray Lewis for awhile.

One thing I would pay attention to is the rumor about Lawrence Timmons being cut. I would rather Denver worked out a trade to get him. It sounds like they are going to use Foote over Timmons.

The Joker
04-20-2010, 05:48 AM
It's OK to run the 3-4 with two good ILB's. The Jets did it last year. They had a pretty good D. The Steelers have had success at it. The Ravens had Bart Scott and Ray Lewis for awhile.

One thing I would pay attention to is the rumor about Lawrence Timmons being cut. I would rather Denver worked out a trade to get him. It sounds like they are going to use Foote over Timmons.

It's not that they're good that's the problem, you want good players.

It's how much you're paying them that is my issue. Harris is still a rookie, I doubt his deal is costing the Jets much. But DJ + a #11 pick? That's a lot tied up in one position.

TonyR
04-20-2010, 05:56 AM
Anybody want Haden at 11.

I don't think he'll make it to 11.

TheReverend
04-20-2010, 06:01 AM
It's OK to run the 3-4 with two good ILB's. The Jets did it last year. They had a pretty good D. The Steelers have had success at it. The Ravens had Bart Scott and Ray Lewis for awhile.

One thing I would pay attention to is the rumor about Lawrence Timmons being cut. I would rather Denver worked out a trade to get him. It sounds like they are going to use Foote over Timmons.

Where'd you hear this? I'd be completely stunned if that happened.

DBroncos4life
04-20-2010, 06:28 AM
Where'd you hear this? I'd be completely stunned if that happened.

Sirius radio. Pretty sure it either came from Gil Brandt or maybe it was Jim Miller when I was listening to late hits. Maybe they are just talking about something that really isn't there though. I was shocked when I heard that as well.

ColoradoBuff
04-20-2010, 07:12 AM
I think if McClain is there at 11...we are gonna take him!

SonOfLe-loLang
04-20-2010, 08:15 AM
i still want weatherspoon. natural leader, good player

Rohirrim
04-20-2010, 08:39 AM
I think "leadership" and "football smarts" will be the two primary elements of every draftee the Broncos look at. Judging by previous comments, Josh feels that McClain fulfills those requirements. I have no doubt he's up high on the Broncos' board. I have my own doubts about him. In the championship game, it appeared to me that McClain was looking to teammates to see how plays were developing and then reacting to their reactions. Not good in a "Mike." Also, is he fast enough to play coverage? He didn't blow anybody away with his pro-days. And he got a lot of protection from that Alabama line. But, what do I know? The Broncos scouts and coaches are going to look at that #1 pick in far more in depth than I ever could.

I don't know why the Broncos would look at Weatherspoon. He's about the same size as Woodyard. I can't imagine he would be any better. In fact, I doubt he would work very well as a WLB in a 3-4. He strikes me as a prototypical Will in a 4-3.

DenverBroncosJM
04-20-2010, 09:19 AM
It changes day to day for me this draft has some amazing guys Broncos could use. This would be ideal from my stand point;

Trade back and get an extra third:

1. 20-24 Pouncey - C
2.1 A. Benn - WR
2.2 Sean Lee - ILB
3.1 John Jerry or Marshall Newhouse - OT/OG
3.2 Toby Gerhart - RB

SonOfLe-loLang
04-20-2010, 09:30 AM
I think "leadership" and "football smarts" will be the two primary elements of every draftee the Broncos look at. Judging by previous comments, Josh feels that McClain fulfills those requirements. I have no doubt he's up high on the Broncos' board. I have my own doubts about him. In the championship game, it appeared to me that McClain was looking to teammates to see how plays were developing and then reacting to their reactions. Not good in a "Mike." Also, is he fast enough to play coverage? He didn't blow anybody away with his pro-days. And he got a lot of protection from that Alabama line. But, what do I know? The Broncos scouts and coaches are going to look at that #1 pick in far more in depth than I ever could.

I don't know why the Broncos would look at Weatherspoon. He's about the same size as Woodyard. I can't imagine he would be any better. In fact, I doubt he would work very well as a WLB in a 3-4. He strikes me as a prototypical Will in a 4-3.

I think Spoon will be good wherever you put him. He's athletic, instinctual, a natural leader, smart, and a born football player. He's bigger than Woodyard and simply a better football player. Im tellin ya, if we draft this guy, he'll be an al wilson-esque fan favorite.

SpringStein
04-20-2010, 10:11 AM
I don't think he'll make it to 11.

My information is that the Raiders have Trent Williams as #1 and Haden as #2 on their board currently. I think Williams will go before their selection, so my guess is it will be Joe Haden to Raiders.

Steve Sewell
04-20-2010, 10:16 AM
Anybody want Haden at 11. I guess his Pro Day was very very good and he would be a nice DB to have against the pass happy offenses of NE, Indi, SD if we ever make it to a playoff game.

Haden has like, this really big mole by one of his ears. He'll need a bigger helmet.

Hamrob
04-20-2010, 11:01 AM
It changes day to day for me this draft has some amazing guys Broncos could use. This would be ideal from my stand point;

Trade back and get an extra third:

1. 20-24 Pouncey - C
2.1 A. Benn - WR
2.2 Sean Lee - ILB
3.1 John Jerry or Marshall Newhouse - OT/OG
3.2 Toby Gerhart - RBI like the Pouncey and Benn picks...but, I'd pass on Lee. All the tape I see on him shows a guy making tackles down the field...not very good blowing up plays ro making tackles for losses.

Hamrob
04-20-2010, 11:04 AM
I think Spoon will be good wherever you put him. He's athletic, instinctual, a natural leader, smart, and a born football player. He's bigger than Woodyard and simply a better football player. Im tellin ya, if we draft this guy, he'll be an al wilson-esque fan favorite.Yeah, I've been comparing him to Woodyard too. He's beefed up to 239lbs...but, is made for the weakside of a 4-3 IMO. I don't see him in the middle of a 3-4. I think he will get blown out by guards coming through. He's firey...I'll give him that. There's also alot of concern about how he might affect a locker room. Rumor is he has a big mouth and NFL Scouts are concerned about that.

Rohirrim
04-20-2010, 11:19 AM
I think Spoon will be good wherever you put him. He's athletic, instinctual, a natural leader, smart, and a born football player. He's bigger than Woodyard and simply a better football player. Im tellin ya, if we draft this guy, he'll be an al wilson-esque fan favorite.

He's only got about ten pounds on Wesley. I just don't see where he'd be that much of an upgrade. To be honest with you, if the Broncos are serious about going LB in the first round, I would hope they pass on both McClain and Spoon, trade down, and take Jerry Hughes. IMO, they would be much happier with him in the long run.

UberBroncoMan
04-20-2010, 11:44 AM
Yup.

Exactly why I think Micah Johnson is on our radar somehwere in the 4th or 5th round. Wouldn't that be sweet. Get rid of Schef and get the 3rd pick of the 5th round and hopefully Micah is there.

http://kentuckysportsradio.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/micah1.jpg

Dude, Micah is slow as ****.

http://www.nfldraftscout.com/ratings/dsprofile.php?pyid=65555&draftyear=2010&genpos=ILB

We didn't get rid of a FASTER Andra Davis just to get a guy who runs a good time for a DT.

He's claimed to hit between 4.7-4.8 though... still slow as ****.

chaz
04-20-2010, 12:21 PM
It changes day to day for me this draft has some amazing guys Broncos could use. This would be ideal from my stand point;

Trade back and get an extra third:

1. 20-24 Pouncey - C
2.1 A. Benn - WR
2.2 Sean Lee - ILB
3.1 John Jerry or Marshall Newhouse - OT/OG
3.2 Toby Gerhart - RB

tears of joy would be flowing freely!

SonOfLe-loLang
04-20-2010, 01:20 PM
Yeah, I've been comparing him to Woodyard too. He's beefed up to 239lbs...but, is made for the weakside of a 4-3 IMO. I don't see him in the middle of a 3-4. I think he will get blown out by guards coming through. He's firey...I'll give him that. There's also alot of concern about how he might affect a locker room. Rumor is he has a big mouth and NFL Scouts are concerned about that.

I dont get why we're comparing guys by measurables alone. Theres a reason spoon is gonna be a first round draft pick and Woodyard was undrafted. If measurables are all we go by, then TJ Duckett should be among the best RB's in the NFL. But he sucks. As far as Spoon's "big mouth" is concerned, ive heard more that he's a leader and well respected than a divisive figure. I think this guy is gonna be a good one and can be a 3 down linebacker. Sure, he's be good in a 4-3, but i think he'd do just fine in the 3-4 and would be an instant starter here. Even McD gushed about him, saying he absorbed everything they threw at him.

long beach bronco
04-20-2010, 01:22 PM
I think we are going to be surprised when Mcd selects CJ Spiller at #11 and say that he was the guy all along.

Triplelefthook
04-20-2010, 01:54 PM
I pesonally don't see ILB as a particularly pressing need. Not only will we have a lot of money locked up at LB but we have adequate players to play SILB already with Larsen and Haggan.

It's not that important to have 4 all star LBs, we have a couple studs already, its the Dline that needs some studs, depth, and money allocation.

I still would have kept Andra Davis, but oh well