All rookie team

[KCStud]

Who ya got on the all rookie team?

[Bronco LB 59]

Not Branden Albert.

[Florida_Bronco]

Not Branden Albert.

:thumbs: :rofl:

[tsiguy96]

the all rookie team would be a pretty stud offense...though i dont know a ton about rookies like corners or safeties/linebackers etc

[Jesterhole]

Matt Ryan vs. Joe Flacco is a tough call. I think you can argue for both Clady and Royal from the Broncos.

[montrose]

QB: Matt Ryan
RB: Matt Forte
RB: Chris Johnson
WR: Eddie Royal
WR: DeSean Jackson
TE: John Carlson
T: Ryan Clady
T: Jeff Otah
G: Mike Pollak
G: Carl Nicks
C: Jamey Richard

DE: Cliff Avril
DE: Trevor Scott
DT: Sedrick Ellis
DT: Pat Sims
LB: Curtis Lofton
LB: Jerod Mayo
LB: Wesley Woodyard
CB: Brandon Flowers
CB: Antoine Cason
S: Chris Horton
S: Charles Godfrey

K: Dan Carpenter
P: Brett Kern

[KCStud]

QB: Matt Ryan
RB: Matt Forte
RB: Chris Johnson
WR: Eddie Royal
WR: DeSean Jackson
TE: John Carlson
T: Ryan Clady
T: Jeff Otah
G: Mike Pollak
G: Carl Nicks
C: Jamey Richard

DE: Cliff Avril
DE: Trevor Scott
DT: Sedrick Ellis
DT: Pat Sims
LB: Curtis Lofton
LB: Jerod Mayo
LB: Wesley Woodyard
CB: Brandon Flowers
CB: Antoine Cason
S: Chris Horton
S: Charles Godfrey

K: Dan Carpenter
P: Brett Kern

Pretty good. I think I would put Aqib Talib in there over Cason. Talib has been a good addition to the Buc's.

[BabyTO]

how can you not have cromartie in there? hes easily the best rookie corner

QB Flacco (BAL)
RB Forte (CHI)
FB Tolbert (SD)
WR Royal (DEN)
WR Jackson (PHI)
TE Keller (NYJ)
OT Clady (DEN)
OG Rachal (SF)
C Richard (IND)
OG Nicks (NO)
OT Long (MIA)

DE Long (STL)
DT Ellis (NO)
DT Harrison (CHI)
DE Scott (OAK)
OLB Rivers (CIN)
MLB Mayo (NE)
OLB Woodyard (DEN)
CB Rodgers-Cromartie (ARI)
CB Talib (TB)
S Phillips (NYG)
S Horton (WAS)

[JJJ]

Matt Ryan vs. Joe Flacco is a tough call. I think you can argue for both Clady and Royal from the Broncos.

If there were ever locks for the all-rookie team Clady and Royal are it.

There is simply no way that Royal kid is a rookie. Phenomenal talent. His size might become an issue regarding injuries but the kid is completely unfazed by the pro game.

[Natedog24]

I think this is the most talented all rookie team ever. So many rookies not just playing well but excelling at their position this year.

[Conklin]

QB: Matt Ryan
RB1: Matt Forte
RB2: Chris Johnson
FB: Peyton Hillis
WR1: Eddie Royal
WR2: Desean Jackson
TE: John Carlson
OT: Ryan Clady
OT: Jake Long
OG: Carl Nicks
OG: Mike Pollack
C: Jamey Richard

DE: Chris Long
DE: Lawrence Jackson
DT: Sedrick Ellis
DT: Pat Sims
OLB: Wesley Woodyard
OLB: Keith Rivers
ILB: Jerod Mayo
CB: Aqib Talib
CB: Brandon Carr
FS: Kenny Phillips
SS: Chris Horton

PK: Garrett Hartley
P: Brett Kern
KR: Leodis McKelvin

[BroncoMan4ever]

If there were ever locks for the all-rookie team Clady and Royal are it.

There is simply no way that Royal kid is a rookie. Phenomenal talent. His size might become an issue regarding injuries but the kid is completely unfazed by the pro game.

i can't see him getting hurt a lot. he lacks a little size, but that dude is nothing but muscle. look at him in interviews he is like a little Incredible Hulk. plus he runs great routes, and knows how to avoid contact after the catch. he is going to become a Steve Smith type of receiver for us. imagine how good he can become, considering his rookie year. dude is still learning the game and kicking ass. i can't wait to see him in 3 years when he is a true veteran. He is going to be a scary mofo for years to come.

[colonelbeef]

Hillis would be there too given a full season

[Inkana7]

Keith Rivers? He played like 4 games before Hines Ward put him on the IR.

QB: Matt Ryan
RB: Matt Forte
RB: Chris Johnson
WR: Eddie Royal
WR: DeSean Jackson
TE: John Carlson
OT: Ryan Clady
OT: Jake Long
OG: Carl Nicks
OG: Mike Pollack
C: Jamey Richard

DE: Chris Long
DE: Trevor Scott
DT: Sedrick Ellis
DT: Marcus Harrison
LB: Jerod Mayo
LB: Wesley Woodyard
LB: Curtis Lofton
S: Chris Horton
S: Charles Godfrey
CB: Brandon Flowers
CB: Domonique Rodgers-Cromartie

P: Brett Kern
K: Dan Carpenter
KR/PR: Clifton Smith

[theAPAOps5]

If there were ever locks for the all-rookie team Clady and Royal are it.

There is simply no way that Royal kid is a rookie. Phenomenal talent. His size might become an issue regarding injuries but the kid is completely unfazed by the pro game.

Yeah size may be an issue but he has done a full season of punt returns and taken the majority of Kick Returns and has fared ok. He did suffer a High Ankle Sprain but has played through it and still been effective. Supposedly it was pretty bad but he toughed it out. So that eases the injury worries a little.

[PRBronco]

If there were ever locks for the all-rookie team Clady and Royal are it.

There is simply no way that Royal kid is a rookie. Phenomenal talent. His size might become an issue regarding injuries but the kid is completely unfazed by the pro game.

We actually had the Chinese forge his documents, he's 28.

[BabyTO]

Keith Rivers? He played like 4 games before Hines Ward put him on the IR.
he was still the best rookie LB in this years class

[Inkana7]

Jerod Mayo begs to differ.

[Conklin]

Keith Rivers? He played like 4 games before Hines Ward put him on the IR.


in four games he was averaging nearly 10 tackles a game, much like our very own OLB Woodyard, also has a pick, a ff, and 2 passes defensed, he still is second among all outside rookie lb's

you've got a 3-4 setup on your list, but have mayo and lofton whom have both played Inside this season

[Inkana7]

I listed LBs. Not specific positions. I feel those three are the three best Rookie LBs this season.

[Conklin]

P: Brett Kern
K: Dan Carpenter
KR/PR: Clifton Smith


you leave out a rookie that hasnt missed a fg and has nearly as many touchbacks as your guys?

and have you seen McKelvin return a kick before? i'm afraid you'll change your mind on this pick after this weekend

[Inkana7]

I have. I watched him go all the way against Cleveland. But I also saw Clifton Smith get a Pro Bowl nod.

[400HZ]

Matt Ryan vs. Joe Flacco is a tough call. I think you can argue for both Clady and Royal from the Broncos.

That's not a tough call at all. Flacco sucks.

[BroncoBuff]

I didn't know Carl Nicks moved to OG .... them Huskers can't do anything right in the NFL :nono:

[TonyR]

how can you not have cromartie in there? hes easily the best rookie corner

QB Flacco (BAL)


You criticize somebody else's list and then you put Flacco over Ryan? Ryan is more obviously the best rookie QB than Rodgers-Cromartie is the best rookie CB.