PDA

View Full Version : Selvin Young or Chester Taylor???


BMF Bronco
12-13-2007, 02:52 PM
I am in the first round of our playoffs and am trying to decide who to start, Young or Taylor?

Los Broncos
12-13-2007, 02:56 PM
Where does Minn play at?

Depending on where, id go with Chester.

BMF Bronco
12-13-2007, 02:57 PM
Chicago

Los Broncos
12-13-2007, 03:00 PM
Chicago

Thats a tough one, Selvin gets yards and Henry punches it in.

Its a toss up bro, but if it was me id go with Chester.

BMF Bronco
12-13-2007, 03:03 PM
But my worry comes in the form of Adrian Peterson getting all the carries this week. NFL.com says to put taylor as a #3 and to put Selvin as a #2.

BMF Bronco
12-13-2007, 03:04 PM
and the other thing is that the dude I am playing has T. Henry for his starter as well.

Los Broncos
12-13-2007, 03:05 PM
But my worry comes in the form of Adrian Peterson getting all the carries this week. NFL.com says to put taylor as a #3 and to put Selvin as a #2.

Then listen to them, do the complete opposite of what i say.

I give sound advice but it seems to backfire.

Los Broncos
12-13-2007, 03:05 PM
and the other thing is that the dude I am playing has T. Henry for his starter as well.

I'm using Henry too, im not confident he will do much.

BMF Bronco
12-13-2007, 03:06 PM
not to mention, NFL.com says that Henry is still being nagged by that knee injury and is going to lose more carries this week

Los Broncos
12-13-2007, 03:09 PM
not to mention, NFL.com says that Henry is still being nagged by that knee injury and is going to lose more carries this week

He'll only really only run in those goal line situations, hes about the only other RB that can punch it in besides Sapp.

So maybe Young is a better play here?

Northman
12-13-2007, 03:10 PM
Thats a tough one, Selvin gets yards and Henry punches it in.

Its a toss up bro, but if it was me id go with Chester.


And thats the best point here. Both Chester and Selvin can gain a lot of yardage but are sometimes relieved by Peterson and Henry. Tough call all the way around. Personally, i would go with Chester but it is tougher than it looks.

BMF Bronco
12-13-2007, 03:18 PM
It's killing me here, I have changed it like 5 times today

Los Broncos
12-13-2007, 03:20 PM
It's killing me here, I have changed it like 5 times today

LOL i feel ya, im having a fight with my brain about my lineup.

Northman
12-13-2007, 03:22 PM
I dont even want to look at mine. Because i know i will do some changing and then screw myself. Last game i had to fight off Romo the Homo. Now, i have Lynch and Marsha Brady. When will the madness end? lol

BMF Bronco
12-13-2007, 03:24 PM
ugh, normally I wouldn't give it much thought, but I came into the playoffs 11-3 and am playing a dude that was undefeated (10-0) until he played me the first time, so he's thirsty for revenge.

Here's the matchups...
HIM ME
Romo Favre
T. Henry L. Tomlinson
E. James S. Young/C. Taylor
S. McDonald B. Marshall
R. Williams B. Engram
L. Coles D. Bowe
Don Lee T. Scheffler
Kris brown R. Bironis
D - NYG INDY

Los Broncos
12-13-2007, 03:25 PM
I dont even want to look at mine. Because i know i will do some changing and then screw myself. Last game i had to fight off Romo the Homo. Now, i have Lynch and Marsha Brady. When will the madness end? lol

:rofl: I'm having a little trouble with a WR, but i think ill leave it alone.

GL this week bro, in the end i think you'll win the match up.

BMF Bronco
12-13-2007, 03:25 PM
Thanks!

Los Broncos
12-13-2007, 03:27 PM
ugh, normally I wouldn't give it much thought, but I came into the playoffs 11-3 and am playing a dude that was undefeated (10-0) until he played me the first time, so he's thirsty for revenge.

Here's the matchups...
HIM ME
Romo Favre
T. Henry L. Tomlinson
E. James S. Young/C. Taylor
S. McDonald B. Marshall
R. Williams B. Engram
L. Coles D. Bowe
Don Lee T. Scheffler
Kris brown R. Bironis
D - NYG INDY

Other than the RB situation, your in good shape.

Northman
12-13-2007, 03:27 PM
ugh, normally I wouldn't give it much thought, but I came into the playoffs 11-3 and am playing a dude that was undefeated (10-0) until he played me the first time, so he's thirsty for revenge.

Here's the matchups...
HIM ME
Romo Favre
T. Henry L. Tomlinson
E. James S. Young/C. Taylor
S. McDonald B. Marshall
R. Williams B. Engram
L. Coles D. Bowe
Don Lee T. Scheffler
Kris brown R. Bironis
D - NYG INDY


Yea, i have Favre also. Ironcially, i beat Lynchmob once this year but his Patriot crew were on a bye. :rofl:

Northman
12-13-2007, 03:28 PM
:rofl: I'm having a little trouble with a WR, but i think ill leave it alone.

GL this week bro, in the end i think you'll win the match up.


Maybe. But Brady is going to torch the Jets D again. I can only hope the weather slows him down some like against the Ravens. Either way, good luck to you as well.

Los Broncos
12-13-2007, 03:28 PM
Thanks!

I was talking to Anubis, but you look to be in good shape.

Doesn't mean you will win.

Thats what is tough about FF huh

Northman
12-13-2007, 03:30 PM
Thanks!

Honestly BMF, if you have LT i wouldnt worry too much. James hasnt been that big a deal this year so i think either Selvin or Chester will win that matchup. You should be good with either in my opinion.

Los Broncos
12-13-2007, 03:32 PM
Yea, i have Favre also. Ironcially, i beat Lynchmob once this year but his Patriot crew were on a bye. :rofl:

Brady gives me all the points, but it all depends on how my other players do.

BMF Bronco
12-13-2007, 03:33 PM
OKAY, this is how i see it, I am going to start Selvin Young, as he is supposed to get the majority of the carries tonight, thus it will do one of two things.

One, since he's starting Henry, I am going to start young so that if young does indeed get the majority of the carries, my plan will work two fold, score me the points and gurantee that one of his rushers will be held to a very minimum.

two, if they do put henry in on the GL, he may get the 6 but hopefully selvie's year total will be enough to cancel that out.

then again, it may blow up in my face and do the exact opposite.

Northman
12-13-2007, 03:34 PM
Brady gives me all the points, but it all depends on how my other players do.

Yea, i hate the fact that Brett is going to a dome but i benched him last week thinking the Raider D would slow down his passing. So much for that so im going to stick with him again and hope he doesnt get hurt.

Los Broncos
12-13-2007, 03:36 PM
OKAY, this is how i see it, I am going to start Selvin Young, as he is supposed to get the majority of the carries tonight, thus it will do one of two things.

One, since he's starting Henry, I am going to start young so that if young does indeed get the majority of the carries, my plan will work two fold, score me the points and gurantee that one of his rushers will be held to a very minimum.

two, if they do put henry in on the GL, he may get the 6 but hopefully selvie's year total will be enough to cancel that out.

then again, it may blow up in my face and do the exact opposite.

Yeah its a crap shoot in the end anyways, i think you'll be ok.

BMF Bronco
12-13-2007, 03:36 PM
Anu, Favre has an awesome history against the lambs, hence why I started him, I have the choice between him and Roethlisburger.

Northman
12-13-2007, 03:37 PM
OKAY, this is how i see it, I am going to start Selvin Young, as he is supposed to get the majority of the carries tonight, thus it will do one of two things.

One, since he's starting Henry, I am going to start young so that if young does indeed get the majority of the carries, my plan will work two fold, score me the points and gurantee that one of his rushers will be held to a very minimum.

two, if they do put henry in on the GL, he may get the 6 but hopefully selvie's year total will be enough to cancel that out.

then again, it may blow up in my face and do the exact opposite.


See, in my league although TD's are worth some good points you also get good points with how many yds you gain as a RB, Qb, and WR, and etc. Sometimes just the yardage is enough to get you over in my league. I think Lynch has hit 100 points at least 3-4 times with brady this year. I know a couple of others have too.

Northman
12-13-2007, 03:38 PM
Anu, Favre has an awesome history against the lambs, hence why I started him, I have the choice between him and Roethlisburger.


Yea, Favre is just having a stellar year. Kind of funny since i took Carson first and Favre later on. But ive been starting Favre most of the year.

BMF Bronco
12-13-2007, 03:43 PM
Here's my dumbass, I took Leinert second round (LT 1st) and didn't take Favre until like the 10th round! what a steal. I pick up worthlessburger when some asshat let him go during his bye week because the dumbass didn't have another QB on the roster, steal #2!

Los Broncos
12-13-2007, 03:46 PM
Here's my dumbass, I took Leinert second round (LT 1st) and didn't take Favre until like the 10th round! what a steal. I pick up worthlessburger when some asshat let him go during his bye week because the dumbass didn't have another QB on the roster, steal #2!

Wow, No one thought Farve would have this good of a year.

Mediator12
12-13-2007, 04:59 PM
I think Young BMF. Chester's touches have been minimal since Peterson returned despite the awesome numbers. At some point, you are not going to score many points on 10 touches a game!

Selvin has some upside tonight, Taylor looks to come back to earth versus CHI.

BMF Bronco
12-13-2007, 05:43 PM
That's kind of what I figured, and even last week, if he didn't break that long one for 80+ he would have benn held in check pretty well. Young it is!

BMF Bronco
12-14-2007, 02:15 AM
well **** that decision didn't work out too well. I only got 3 points from him, however, I can take solace in the fact that he had Henry, who only got two points. But I had Scheff and Marshall who combined for 26 points.

Los Broncos
12-14-2007, 02:38 AM
well **** that decision didn't work out too well. I only got 3 points from him, however, I can take solace in the fact that he had Henry, who only got two points. But I had Scheff and Marshall who combined for 26 points.

Yeah Chester may have been the best bet, but you got points from the others.

I got 30 points from Mario Williams.

BMF Bronco
12-14-2007, 11:17 AM
no too worried about it I am winning 29-9

Northman
12-14-2007, 12:28 PM
Yeah Chester may have been the best bet, but you got points from the others.

I got 30 points from Mario Williams.



Yea, yea, yea. :rofl:

Los Broncos
12-14-2007, 01:56 PM
Yea, yea, yea. :rofl:

I checked today i got 40 from him.

Not that i wanted it that way but there is a lot of football left.

Everyone picked you to win our match up.

Northman
12-14-2007, 05:18 PM
I checked today i got 40 from him.

Not that i wanted it that way but there is a lot of football left.

Everyone picked you to win our match up.


Well, you needed him to step up. Henry did hardly anything for you. Hopefully all my guys come through this weekend.

Los Broncos
12-14-2007, 05:38 PM
Well, you needed him to step up. Henry did hardly anything for you. Hopefully all my guys come through this weekend.

Yeah, Henry did nothing like i expected.

I had no other choice on the RB's,

Its going to come down to what Brady does.

BMF Bronco
12-17-2007, 05:51 PM
So I ended up winning 109-47!

muahahahaha, in the championship baby!!!!!!!!