Who is best college QB ever

[Billy Clyde Puckett]

Ok - Time to stir up some trouble here.

Who is the best college QB you have ever seen. Remeber college career only, not pro.

While the single greatest performances I have seen were Elway's games against Oklahoma and Ohio State, for an entire college career, the best I have seen was Bob Griese. He was technically perfect, seldom made a mistake and was always in complete control of the game. Sometimes you wondered when watching him if the game was scripted from start to finish.

[Tom H.]

Sal Aunese- He's the best without being "the best"

How about FSU's Charlie Ward?

[Rocket 7]

The greatest performance I saw was Doug Flutie on Thanksgiving 1984 against the defending natoinal champs Miami.

[BRONCCRUSHFAN]

Ty Detmer has to be up there, those BYU teams were unstoppable.

[Billy Clyde Puckett]

The greatest performance I saw was Doug Flutie on Thanksgiving 1984 against the defending natoinal champs Miami.

I have the Elway vs. OSU game on VHS tape. I should get it duped on DVD and make it available to Maners. Faderproof would have a nervous breakdown watching that game and not knowing who to cheer for.

[JPEZ]

John Elway! DUH! ;D

[FADERPROOF]

I have the Elway vs. OSU game on VHS tape. I should get it duped on DVD and make it available to Maners. Faderproof would have a nervous breakdown watching that game and not knowing who to cheer for.

My dad has told me about the game, said it was an icnredible performance all around, but make no mistake that with Elway or not, Id be cheering for the Buckeyes.

Best college QB that I've seen was Peyton Manning(which is why I'm such a fan of his as a pro.) I still to this day say that he was robbed of the Heisman is senior year, Moss had more claim to the trophy than Woodson did.

[Evenrude]

I know some will call me a homer for this one but.....

Tommy Frazier.

School records:

• Total offense, career (5,476 yards)
• Touchdown passes, career (43)
• Rushing touchdowns by a quarterback, career (36)
• Total offensive touchdowns, career (79)
• Rushing touchdowns by a quarterback, season (14)
• Rushing yards in a bowl game (199)*
• Total offense in a bowl game (304 yards)
• Longest touchdown run in a bowl game (75 yards)**
* NCAA record for rushing yards by a quarterback in a bowl
** Named ESPY college football play of the year.

Major awards

• Football Writers 1995 First Team All American
• Walter Camp 1995 First Team All American
• Associated Press 1995 First Team All American
• United Press International 1995 First Team All American
• AFCA 1995 First Team All American
• Johnny Unitas Golden Arm Award 1995
• Sporting News Offensive Player of the Year 1995
• TD Club of Columbus Quarterback of the Year 1995
• Big Eight Offensive Player of the Year 1995
• 1996 Fiesta Bowl Most Valuable Player
• 1994 and 1995 Orange Bowl Most Valuable Player
• 1992 Big Eight Freshman of the Year
• Sport magazine Top 10 Players of the Century

(borrowed from Huskerpedia.com (http://www.huskerpedia.com/tommie.html))

Tommie was at his best in big games. He won two national titles and was a bounce/call away from winning a third (Fla St. 1993) where he outplayed Heisman winner Charlie Ward as a sophmore.

http://i.a.cnn.net/si/2005/football/ncaa/specials/bowls/2004/01/05/perfect.seasons/p1_frazier_all.jpg

[Master___Pain]

I know some will call me a homer for this one but.....

Tommy Frazier.

http://i.a.cnn.net/si/2005/football/ncaa/specials/bowls/2004/01/05/perfect.seasons/p1_frazier_all.jpg
Sadly, I have to agree with you. That run against UF is legendary.

I need to disinfect my keyboard after typing that, I feel so dirty. (He should have been a buff, but Mac changed the O and Tommy changed his mind and went to nu. The horror)

A QB I got to see a lot of growing up that was an amazing option QB was Dee Dowis of AFA. He was one of the first 1000-1000 guys.

[Rocket 7]

I know some will call me a homer for this one but.....

Tommy Frazier.

School records:

• Total offense, career (5,476 yards)
• Touchdown passes, career (43)
• Rushing touchdowns by a quarterback, career (36)
• Total offensive touchdowns, career (79)
• Rushing touchdowns by a quarterback, season (14)
• Rushing yards in a bowl game (199)*
• Total offense in a bowl game (304 yards)
• Longest touchdown run in a bowl game (75 yards)**
* NCAA record for rushing yards by a quarterback in a bowl
** Named ESPY college football play of the year.

Major awards

• Football Writers 1995 First Team All American
• Walter Camp 1995 First Team All American
• Associated Press 1995 First Team All American
• United Press International 1995 First Team All American
• AFCA 1995 First Team All American
• Johnny Unitas Golden Arm Award 1995
• Sporting News Offensive Player of the Year 1995
• TD Club of Columbus Quarterback of the Year 1995
• Big Eight Offensive Player of the Year 1995
• 1996 Fiesta Bowl Most Valuable Player
• 1994 and 1995 Orange Bowl Most Valuable Player
• 1992 Big Eight Freshman of the Year
• Sport magazine Top 10 Players of the Century

(borrowed from Huskerpedia.com (http://www.huskerpedia.com/tommie.html))

Tommie was at his best in big games. He won two national titles and was a bounce/call away from winning a third (Fla St. 1993) where he outplayed Heisman winner Charlie Ward as a sophmore.

http://i.a.cnn.net/si/2005/football/ncaa/specials/bowls/2004/01/05/perfect.seasons/p1_frazier_all.jpg

That play against Florida in the Fiesta Bowl was just amazing. (From were that picture was taken) It looked at least three Gators had him before he broke loose. They were a last second Bryon Bennett field goal away from winning the 1994 Orange Bowl.

[Rocket 7]

A QB I got to see a lot of growing up that was an amazing option QB was Dee Dowis of AFA. He was one of the first 1000-1000 guys.

I didn't know that I always thought Beau Morgan was the first AFA QB to go 1000-1000.

[SoCalBronco]

I dont know who is the best but i was really impressed with Steve Stenstrom of Stanford and John Walsh of BYU.

[SouthStndJunkie]

Best college QB that I've seen was Peyton Manning(which is why I'm such a fan of his as a pro.) I still to this day say that he was robbed of the Heisman is senior year, Moss had more claim to the trophy than Woodson did.

If he could have only beaten Florida.

SSJ

[Rocket 7]

Sammy Baugh deserves at least some consideration. TCU

[Florida_Bronco]

I know some will call me a homer for this one but.....

Tommy Frazier.

School records:

• Total offense, career (5,476 yards)
• Touchdown passes, career (43)
• Rushing touchdowns by a quarterback, career (36)
• Total offensive touchdowns, career (79)
• Rushing touchdowns by a quarterback, season (14)
• Rushing yards in a bowl game (199)*
• Total offense in a bowl game (304 yards)
• Longest touchdown run in a bowl game (75 yards)**
* NCAA record for rushing yards by a quarterback in a bowl
** Named ESPY college football play of the year.

Major awards

• Football Writers 1995 First Team All American
• Walter Camp 1995 First Team All American
• Associated Press 1995 First Team All American
• United Press International 1995 First Team All American
• AFCA 1995 First Team All American
• Johnny Unitas Golden Arm Award 1995
• Sporting News Offensive Player of the Year 1995
• TD Club of Columbus Quarterback of the Year 1995
• Big Eight Offensive Player of the Year 1995
• 1996 Fiesta Bowl Most Valuable Player
• 1994 and 1995 Orange Bowl Most Valuable Player
• 1992 Big Eight Freshman of the Year
• Sport magazine Top 10 Players of the Century

(borrowed from Huskerpedia.com (http://www.huskerpedia.com/tommie.html))

Tommie was at his best in big games. He won two national titles and was a bounce/call away from winning a third (Fla St. 1993) where he outplayed Heisman winner Charlie Ward as a sophmore.

http://i.a.cnn.net/si/2005/football/ncaa/specials/bowls/2004/01/05/perfect.seasons/p1_frazier_all.jpg

REP!!

I can still hear the announcers going "How many tackles can one man break?!?" I think I'm gonna go find that old tape and watch that game again ^5

Also, I think Brook Berringer could have very well been the best had he not been behind Frazier, that boy had loads of talent and was the definition of a team player.