PDA

View Full Version : Trade advice, debating this trade not sure if I should do it. Reggie bush, Steve Smith, Witten for


KevinJames
09-18-2013, 11:47 PM
I get Wes Welker, Vernon Davis, David Wilson I give up Reggie Bush, Steve Smith, Witten.

Should I do it?

Drek
09-19-2013, 04:30 AM
I get Wes Welker, Vernon Davis, David Wilson I give up Reggie Bush, Steve Smith, Witten.

Should I do it?

What format? Namely is it a PPR?

In a PPR I'd definitely rather have Witten than Davis, and in a non-PPR I'd consider them a pretty close tie with Davis having more upside but Witten more consistency.

Welker will be boom/bust week to week while Smith is the #1 in Carolina by a mile, so again consistency, but Welker will have higher peak weeks in a PPR league as his 100 yard games will come on 8-10 catches while Smith's can come on 3-6 catches.

Bush is clearly a better fantasy option than David Wilson at this point. The Giants offense has been bad and Wilson has put it on the ground a bunch. Jacobs is likely going to goal line vulture him going forward.

I personally wouldn't do it in any format.