PDA

View Full Version : Fantasy Football Trade Help


Broncoman13
10-18-2012, 01:26 PM
I am being offered both of the folllowing trades:

Trent Richardson
Hardesty
Julio Jones

For

Darren McFadden
Brandon Marshall

Or

Richardson
Hardesty
Antonio Brown

For

McFadden
Mike Wallace

Which deal is better and who is gaining the most?

Which players would you prefer. Keep in mind that McFadden has been poor but has the easiset schedule remaining with 9 out of the next 10 vs defenses that rank 20th or worse vs the run.

Broncoman13
10-18-2012, 02:25 PM
No help?

ludo21
10-18-2012, 02:26 PM
id take the first one.

cutthemdown
10-18-2012, 02:45 PM
I am being offered both of the folllowing trades:

Trent Richardson
Hardesty
Julio Jones

For

Darren McFadden
Brandon Marshall

Or

Richardson
Hardesty
Antonio Brown

For

McFadden
Mike Wallace

Which deal is better and who is gaining the most?

Which players would you prefer. Keep in mind that McFadden has been poor but has the easiset schedule remaining with 9 out of the next 10 vs defenses that rank 20th or worse vs the run.

Are you PPR?

DBroncos4life
10-18-2012, 02:49 PM
Do you need the RB? Not sure I would do either of those.

cutthemdown
10-18-2012, 02:52 PM
Richardson may or may not be banged up right now. Mcfadden you have to believe will break out over next few games. If you are a keeper league though do the trade. Richardson and Jones have more value going forward. But Marshall lots of value in PPR, I think he finishes top 5 WR in that format. Wallace and Brown not as consistent in a PPR.

How are you looking for the playoffs? As in does it look like you will make them for sure. If so check the matchups last few weeks of the season. Which one has the better matchup is really a big factor.

Good luck. I have Marshal on my fantasy team and probably would not do the trade. My thinking being Richardson banged up, could get worst, McFadden yet to break out but IMO will. But then with Jones he could get sat at the end of the yr. Falcons 6-0 and could run away with division. If that happens players that get dinged often dont play as much, or get sat as a precaution. Lots of ways to get screwed.

Broncoman13
10-18-2012, 04:31 PM
Not a PPR. Richardson was a 3rd round pick, McFadden a 1st so I would have a 3 round keeper in Richardson.

My WRs are Nelson, Marshall, Wallace, Austin, and Amendola.

RBs are Rice, McFadden, Green, and DeAngelo Williams.

I am also trying to deal Miles Austin and Mike Vick for Peyton Manning.

If you think McFadden will break out, I will stick with him. He has the easiest schedule over the next 10 games. Really easy! But he has only gone over 100 once and not scoring much.

Not gonna get rid of BMarsh! Way too much value with him. Even in a non PPR, the targets and catches lead to opportunity for production.

Not sold on McFadden at all tho... :/

Chris
10-18-2012, 04:38 PM
Take the first one.

TheReverend
10-18-2012, 04:41 PM
First one or sit on what you have.

canadianbroncosfan
10-18-2012, 04:45 PM
I'd say neither

Your WR core seems weaker than your RB, especially with Amendola gone and both trades you downgrade (based on Fanstasy performance so far) at that position.

Broncoman13
10-18-2012, 09:09 PM
Amendola is done for the season?

DENVERDUI55
10-18-2012, 09:14 PM
Amendola is done for the season?

No he is supposed to be back in a few weeks. I have to ask the OP how do you have that many great WR's are there only a couple teams in your league?

canadianbroncosfan
10-18-2012, 10:17 PM
Amendola is done for the season?

My bad, I read an article shortly after his injury that he had separated his shoulder and was done. Not having him on either fantasy team, I never followed up. My bad guys. Looks like he'll miss at least another three games.

Jekyll15Hyde
10-18-2012, 11:05 PM
I would take neither. Hardesty doesnt matter so its a 2 for 2.

maven
10-18-2012, 11:26 PM
Not a PPR. Richardson was a 3rd round pick, McFadden a 1st so I would have a 3 round keeper in Richardson.

My WRs are Nelson, Marshall, Wallace, Austin, and Amendola.

RBs are Rice, McFadden, Green, and DeAngelo Williams.

I am also trying to deal Miles Austin and Mike Vick for Peyton Manning.

If you think McFadden will break out, I will stick with him. He has the easiest schedule over the next 10 games. Really easy! But he has only gone over 100 once and not scoring much.

Not gonna get rid of BMarsh! Way too much value with him. Even in a non PPR, the targets and catches lead to opportunity for production.

Not sold on McFadden at all tho... :/

Richardson is banged up now so I wouldn't make that trade this week. I would wait and I wouldn't want to lose Marshall.

s0phr0syne
10-19-2012, 12:01 AM
Hold. Both deals suck.

Broncoman13
10-19-2012, 05:27 AM
No he is supposed to be back in a few weeks. I have to ask the OP how do you have that many great WR's are there only a couple teams in your league?

I went WR heavy in the draft. Drafted Nelson and Marshall in the 2nd and 3rd then drafted Wallace and Austin in the 4th and 5th. There was a run on TEs so waited until later and got Tony Gonzalez in the 8th or 9th. Amendola was a FA pick up! Suffering at RB as a result. Really, it is a QB league though. The top tier QBs put up 35 points or better routinely. I am currently carrying 4 QBs and trying to play matchups. Trying to send Austin and Vick for Peyton Manning right now.

10 team league. Pot right now is up to $1750 because of luxury tax and FA priority tax that was put in place. I have a 2-4 record, but my two wins were high point weeks so won $28 for both of those weeks. Top 3 teams from each division make the playoffs and fortunately I am only one game out of 2nd place in my division. But I am playing our division leader who is 6-0. He is carried by RGIII and AJ Green.

Just need that stud QB and I will be good to go!

Broncoman13
10-19-2012, 05:28 AM
Let me ask this question, if I can get him to go Richardson and Julio Jones for McFadden and Mike Wallace, should I do that one?

Rascal
10-19-2012, 07:31 AM
I have no problem moving McFadden, but neither of those deals improve your team.

maher_tyler
10-19-2012, 07:45 AM
I'd keep what you have if you haven't accepted the Trade already...

maher_tyler
10-19-2012, 07:48 AM
Amendola is done for the season?

I had him and dropped him for Kenny Britt.

Elway 4 Life
10-19-2012, 08:34 AM
Let me ask this question, if I can get him to go Richardson and Julio Jones for McFadden and Mike Wallace, should I do that one?

No way. Julio is a monster and is just gonna get better. Wallace is a poor route runner and McFadden has bot done much. TR is banged up but he's pretty much there whole offense.

My take on your OP is that u should stay with what u have.

canadianbroncosfan
10-19-2012, 10:52 AM
No way. Julio is a monster and is just gonna get better. Wallace is a poor route runner and McFadden has bot done much. TR is banged up but he's pretty much there whole offense.

My take on your OP is that u should stay with what u have.

Is this post basically telling him to go for it?

He has McFadden and Wallace and would get Jones and Richardson.

If you can pull that off, then this guy is an idiot. So take advantage all that you can.

Elway 4 Life
10-19-2012, 12:47 PM
Is this post basically telling him to go for it?

He has McFadden and Wallace and would get Jones and Richardson.

If you can pull that off, then this guy is an idiot. So take advantage all that you can.

Yes! Lol. I totally read that wrong. First option is good. A fleece job IMO.

jerseyboiler120
10-19-2012, 03:59 PM
Take the first one. Definitely don't take the 2nd one.

maven
10-19-2012, 11:27 PM
Take the first one. Definitely don't take the 2nd one.

yeah it's the only option. My only hesitation is how those ribs will hold up the rest of the season even though he's a young buck. Browns though need him bad to run the ball.

Aftermath
10-20-2012, 01:57 AM
What is your honest opinion on these two trades. 12 team league PPR.
My team :
QB Luck/Schaub
WR Bowe
WR Harvin
WR S. Johnson
RB Rice
RB MJD
WR/RB Lynch
TE Olsen
Bench
Green-Ellis
Mendenhall
Wells
Blackmon
F. Jones

The trades that got accepted last week.

Green-Ellis
Steve Johnson
For
Larry Fitzgerald
B. Tate

Jones-Drew
Bowe
For
D. Thomas(!!!!)
H. Nicks

I think I did REAL well on the first trade and it all depends on Nicks for second trade. I needed better receivers since its PPR so I made the trades. I kind of panicked on the 2nd one because I'm fricken 2-4 with the 3rd most points and have 230 more points scored AGAINST me than than 1st place guy. I have the worst luck ever. Anyways what you think?

Updated team:
Luck
Fitzgerald
DT
Nicks
Rice
Lynch
Harvin
Olsen

cutthemdown
10-20-2012, 02:09 AM
That team should kick ass. Fitz and Harvin both having good yrs, Rice the best RB outside of foster, DT getting to be a stud. Good luck.